• Home
  • About
  • #SAchat
    • About #SAchat
    • #SAchat Archives
    • #SAchat Awards
  • More
    • Leadership Team
    • Be a Writer
    • SA Directory
  • #SAReads

Sometimes It’s Not About the Roses


Posted by Matt Pistilli on 03 May 2011 / 15 Comments



Sunshine, lollipops and rainbows everywhere…

There are times that I believe that this song must be the mantra of student affairs staff members.   So often on Twitter or Facebook, in meetings, or at trainings, I hear the phrase “choose your attitude.”

Choose to be positive, not negative.
Choose to look on the bright side, not the dark side.
Choose to be happy (or at least content), not sad.
Choose to be something other than pessimistic.
Look for the unicorns!  Look for the puppies! Look! Choose to see them!  They’re there if you look!
Choose.

Generally, I’m ok with this.

Sometimes, however, I’m not.
Sometimes things are difficult.
Sometimes things are challenging.
Sometimes things are just downright awful, and, sometimes, there is not a happy-go-lucky, cheery, paint-a-smile-on-your-face feeling to be found.

And yet what do I hear?

Choose your attitude.  Or, to put it in FiSH philosophy terms, choose your ’tude.

To me, this is largely disingenuous.   Why, exactly, are we putting on a happy face when things legitimately are not happy?  What service are we providing by pretending to be OK with whatever is going on when we actually need support and the ability to be not happy.

We encourage our students and coworkers to be honest. We discuss authenticity with our colleagues and supervisors.  We have open doors and welcome the opportunity to talk to whomever about whatever whenever.

We should reserve the right to have crappy days and to not be forced to look/feel/act otherwise.

I admit… I can be a proverbial bucket of sunshine at times. I can exude rainbows and look for the silver lining in situations with the best of them. But sometimes things suck, and that’s that.

In my mind, it boils down to this.  I have the right to be upset, angry, annoyed, pessimistic, sad, dejected, or whatever other negative feeling there is.  I have the responsibility, though, to give others a heads up about what they might encounter should they choose to engage me in conversation.  I also have the responsibility, after an appropriate amount of time (dependent on the situation), to move on, get over myself, and revert to my unicorn-loving self.

In the interim, though, let me be.  And let me show a genuine side of life to my students – because if they can see me being productive and tactful even while harboring a less-than-stellar attitude, maybe they, too, can learn to channel negative energy positively.

Matt Pistilli is a post-doctoral research associate/educational technologist for Information Technology at Purdue University.

Written by Matt Pistilli


  • http://twitter.com/Kathy_Petras Kathy Petras

    Great post. As someone who works in an office that talks about the FISH! Philosophy all the time, I definitely agree with you. And we do remind each other to “Choose our Attitudes” but sometimes the response is “I did choose & I’m choosing to be a bit cranky right now.” So your post definitely resonated with me. Thanks! :)

  • http://twitter.com/mddeeg Matthew Deeg

    Wow, what a challenging post. I’m with you that we are often told to pick our attitude, and I’ve been guilty of saying the same thing. When we are in a bad mood, does it boil down to controlling our emotions and not allowing them to control us? Because I can see an instance when I’m really upset about something, but I don’t let that affect my interactions with students (even if they can tell I’m not all sunshine/rainbows).

  • http://twitter.com/JenniferKeegin Jennifer Keegin

    Preach on! I am huge on choosing your attitude and I guess it usually boils down for me to a situation where when things are at their worst – if I need to – I have to choose the way in which I speak about my anger, frustration or disappointment while students are around. I keep things respectful or take myself out of a situation that I know will lead to inappropriate “sharing” due to overwhelming stress or etc.

    I have to share this because this is down the same vein – super stressful week this week for me. I’m in charge of Leadership Awards night followed by Spring Fling on Saturday. I am choosing my attitude and in doing so I’m wearing a pin that says I’M KIND OF A BIG DEAL. I chose to go with the ridiculous to help soften the manic.

  • http://twitter.com/DRozeboom Dave Rozeboom

    I like that you stressed authenticity and responsibility as much as attitude. Nice job!

  • Anonymous

    Love this. I hate the idea of “choose your attitude, as long as it’s what I want you to choose.”

  • http://twitter.com/cindykane Cindy Kane

    Loved this post and what it will bring to our discussion of the field. Being open and honest about things we struggle with is an important part of authentic leadership for sure. I am, though, a big believer in the action of decision making and how it shapes attitude. I’m also a fan of those folks who can smile their way through difficult circumstances when it’s called upon. In our field, the mastery is in knowing when it’s called upon and in what circumstances.

    When I’ve done the FISH! Training before the “Choose your Attitude” mantra has frequently been translated into “Choose to be Happy.” Sometimes I make a decision to stay annoyed because it’s going to help me figure out what to do next and I”m not ready to “get over it.”

    Sometimes, that’s when I get my best ideas on what strategy comes next!

  • Scott M. Helfrich

    Well stated, Matt.

    I highly recommend checking out the book “Bright-sided: How Positive Thinking is Undermining America” by Barbara Ehrenreich which gets to the heart of exactly what you’ve written about!

    You can see exerpts from the book and video interviews at:
    http://www.barbaraehrenreich.com/brightsided.htm

  • http://twitter.com/gallagb brian gallagher

    True stuff Matt- thanks for posting this.
    I agree, sometimes I’m just in a bad mood- it usually has nothing to do with you. (the proverbial you)

  • http://twitter.com/kevincleary kevincleary

    I completely agree! I understand that I do choose my attitude. sometimes, though, I choose to be sad, just as I choose to be happy other times. We need to focus more on the understanding that everyone’s attitude is a choice, but it is not a choice we can make for others. Great post Matt!

  • Erin Morrell

    I love this post! I agree! We try to stay positive all of the time and sometimes it’s just not a reality. Some days do suck and we just want to crawl back into bed and say screw it. Overall, I try to have a positive attitude and outlook on work, life and in general. I think its’ good sometimes to vent out the negative feelings – especially to someone you trust – for me it’s a stress relief and I can go back to the “bucket of sunshine” as you mentioned in your post. Thanks for sharing!

  • http://selldrugsshop.dlinkddns.com/Ivermectin-Dose-Dog-Mange.html Krasnov1955

    I have to show some thanks to this writer just for rescuing me from this type of problem. After exploring throughout the the net and seeing ways which are not pleasant, I assumed my entire life was done. Existing without the presence of approaches to the problems you’ve resolved by way of your entire blog post is a critical case, and the ones which might have badly damaged my entire career if I hadn’t noticed your website. Your own talents and kindness in handling a lot of stuff was crucial. I’m not sure what I would have done if I hadn’t discovered such a point like this. I am able to at this point relish my future. Thanks for your time so much for the professional and result oriented guide. I will not be reluctant to propose your blog to anybody who will need support on this subject.

    Read more on my blog Mexican glyburide.

  • Pingback: peak property and casualty insurance

  • Pingback: Fathers Day Gifts

  • Jeffrey Cufaude

    Love this post.  I’m not sure, however that we have to equate “Choose Your Attitude” with “Put on a Happy Face.”  If that’s where we’re at with the FISH philosophy, we’re in deep trouble.

    As you note, we can choose to be upset or irritated while also choosing to model to others that we can fulfill our professional responsibilities at the same time. That seems like the emotionally intelligent approach.

  • Pingback: writing services

  • Latest Activity

  • Tags

    #sabest #sachat 9/11 acpa Advice advising career Community Conferences Education and Technology Education Theory engagement facebook Graduate Students higher ed Higher Education how to ideas interviews Job Search leadership leadership development NASPA Orientation Personal Poll professional development reflection residence life social justice Social Media student activities Student Affairs student affairs technology Student Development Student Engagement Student Engagement Theory students Supervision technology This and that Top Content Twitter Uncategorized video
  • Search

  • Archives

  • Categories




Copyright © 2012 Swift Kick